Thursday, May 16, 2019

5 Favorite Films of the '50s for Classic Movie Day


The Final Five


Who among committed classic film bloggers could possibly resist the chance to join a blogathon honoring National Classic Movie Day? I couldn’t, but this year’s blog-fest posed a tough challenge.

The Classic Film and TV Café aka/Rick, its founder, is once more hosting a National Classic Movie Day Blogathon. This year participants were challenged to choose and elaborate on their five favorite films of the ‘50s. Only five. From the ‘50s. Impossible. I made the effort and eventually whittled my list down to 10 or so films, but other titles continued to pop into my head, so I decided to go at it from another angle.

What I’ve done is take a look at the films of two popular stars, two filmmakers and a studio that were all at their peak during the decade and then selected one favorite from each out of their 1950s filmographies. Here goes… 


Vincente Minnelli: The Bad and the Beautiful (1952)

Kirk Douglas and Lana Turner in The Bad and the Beautiful

Vincente Minnelli broke out as a Hollywood director in 1944 with Meet Me in St. Louis, the biggest movie of the year. He would have his hits and misses during the ‘40s, directing a mixed bag of films including the romantic drama The Clock (1945), Yolanda and the Thief (1945), a musical, the noir drama Undercurrent (1946), The Pirate (1948), another musical, and an adaptation of Madame Bovary (1949). The 1950s would bring his greatest achievements and many of his films, also in a mix of genres, are, along with being bona fide classics, favorites of mine: Father of the Bride (1950), An American in Paris (1951), The Bad and the Beautiful (1952), The Band Wagon (1953), Gigi (1958) and Some Came Running (1958).

Gloria Grahame with her Oscar
I chose The Bad and the Beautiful as my top Minnelli pick of the ‘50s. A good part of its appeal for me is that it is a Hollywood movie about Hollywood, from the town's early days to mid-century. The story unfolds in a series of three individual flashbacks, the reminiscences of a producer/director, a writer and a leading lady who look back on their relationships with wunderkind producer Jonathan Shields (Kirk Douglas). A sumptuous film – among the five Oscars won are those for costume design (Helen Rose) and art direction (110 sets were used, 10 for scenes within scenes) - it is strewn with a slew of references to movie insider knowledge and private jokes. Douglas, in a star-making turn, portrays a charismatic and compulsively driven mogul-on-the-rise in the vein of David O. Selznick, with hints of Darryl F. Zanuck and Orson Welles; a scene following a fatal plane crash mirrors Clark Gable’s reaction when his wife, Carole Lombard, was lost in a similar tragedy; elements of Lana Turner’s character are said to be based on John Barrymore’s daughter, Diana. And more. Then there’s Gloria Grahame in her Oscar-winning supporting performance as the seductive southern belle wife (Zelda Fitzgerald?) of a novelist-turned-screenwriter (Dick Powell). When Gloria’s on the screen she lights it up with a sparkle and glow like no other, and The Bad and the Beautiful is a film that glitters all the more radiantly with her presence.

The Bad and the Beautiful is a big, brash melodrama about Hollywood movers and shakers behind the scenes and the scheming and dreaming and hard work that goes into the making of movies. The lead performances are larger than life, the sets are sometimes mammoth, and the story itself is vast in its scope. All of this is powerfully enhanced and accentuated by one of the greatest of all film scores, the work of legendary composer David Raksin, who also scored Laura in 1944 and would be Oscar nominated for Forever Amber (1947) and Separate Tables (1958). Raksin deserved an Oscar for his score for The Bad and the Beautiful, one of the very best and most successful films of 1952, it would’ve been quite a bit less beautiful without his music. However, and in keeping with the vagaries of Hollywood portrayed in the movie, neither Raksin nor Minnelli would so much as receive an Oscar nomination.

Watch the trailer, listen to the score...



 Audrey Hepburn: Roman Holiday (1953)
 
Eddie Albert, Audrey Hepburn and Gregory Peck in Roman Holiday

Audrey Hepburn stepped onto the world stage in 1953 with her first starring film role as Princess Ann in William Wyler’s Roman Holiday.  She would take the Best Actress Oscar for her performance and go on to star in two Billy Wilder films, Sabrina (1954) and Love in the Afternoon (1957), during the ‘50s, Funny Face (1957) for Stanley Donen, and The Nun’s Story (1959) for Fred Zinnemann; she would earn Best Actress Oscar nominations for Sabrina and The Nun’s Story. She would continue her rise through the 1960s with performances in films like Breakfast at Tiffany’s (1961), Charade (1963), My Fair Lady (1964), How to Steal a Million (1966), Two for the Road (1967) and Wait Until Dark (1967). She was Oscar nominated for Breakfast at Tiffany’s and Wait Until Dark.  At this point she took a break from acting and embraced motherhood, not returning to the screen until 1976. She made only five more films prior to her death in 1993. By then Audrey Hepburn was a legend – as an actress, a style icon and a humanitarian.

Audrey Hepburn with her Oscar
So. Roman Holiday. Why? To begin with, this is a treasure of a film, William Wyler’s romantic postwar-modern fairytale about a runaway European princess and an American “commoner” (Gregory Peck) who teeter on the brink of love and, after a fleeting adventure in the eternal city, come to a wistful, bittersweet goodbye. The film deservedly earned a Best Picture nomination, as well as nine more, including three wins.  One of these justifiable wins was for the screenplay and given to Ian McLellan, who was fronting for Dalton Trumbo (Kitty Foyle/1940, Spartacus/1960, etc.), then on the blacklist. In 1993 McLellan’s name was removed and the award credited to Trumbo. Gregory Peck is perfectly cast as the journalist torn between getting the big story and hanging onto his integrity, and second lead Eddie Albert provides a good dose of affable comic relief.

There are so many reasons to favor Roman Holiday, one of the finest romantic comedies of the 1950s. But I chose it mostly because of Audrey Hepburn. I suppose it would’ve been possible at the time for another young European actress, one with similar film experience, to have been given the role. For example, gamine Leslie Caron, a gifted actress from France, who had already made an impression with An American in Paris. Or, perhaps, delicate Pier Angeli, from Italy, who was, like Audrey, emerging in the early ‘50s. Either of them, or another, might’ve been well-suited to the part and the film still might’ve worked well. Being of Old World royalty, the princess would certainly have been a young lady of refinement and elegance, and other young actresses could have portrayed that with no trouble. But the combination of curiosity, tenderness and vivacity that Audrey brings to the character, along with her own understated glamour and elfin charisma, make for an enchanting Princess Ann, an entirely beguiling ingenue.  It was the best possible career launch for the actress and an ideal introduction for movie-goers to the magic of Audrey Hepburn.

Roman Holiday - The Mouth of Truth


Alfred Hitchcock: Rear Window (1954)

James Stewart and Grace Kelly in Rear Window

The 10 years spanning 1951 – 1960 encompassed Hitchcock’s “Golden Decade.” It began with Strangers on a Train (1951), ended with Psycho (1960), and included Rear Window (1954), Vertigo (1958) and North by Northwest (1959), to mention the rest of Alfred Hitchcock’s 1950s crème de la crème. Truthfully, it would be impossible for me to pick a favorite between Strangers, Rear Window and Vertigo. And so, continuing to be honest about it, I chose Rear Window because it is the only film among “the cream” that I haven’t blogged about yet.

Alfred Hitchcock spoke passionately of “pure cinema,” the technique of relating a story visually, through cinematography, editing and sound design with less emphasis on dialogue. He was a master of the art and the best of his films offer viewers a chance to participate in an immersive experience by way of his brilliant, in his words, “juxtaposition of pieces of the film.”  

Raymond Burr in Rear Window
Rear Window is one of Hitchcock’s most effective exercises in pure cinema. The story concerns a man, Jeff Jeffries (James Stewart), who is wheelchair-bound in his oppressive apartment, convalescing with a broken leg. He is confined to this room throughout the entire film. He gets bored and begins looking out the window of his rear-facing apartment into the windows of his neighbors – with the help of a pair of binoculars. He becomes suspicious of what’s going on in an apartment directly across from his and begins to conspire with friends and associates (Grace Kelly, Wendell Corey, Thelma Ritter) to do some snooping. In other hands this kind of story could end up looking like a filmed single-set stage play. Rear Window is anything but that. It opens with a leisurely panning shot that takes in the scene of the various apartments and neighbors Jeff will be observing once he picks up his binoculars. The camera then sweeps through the main room of his apartment, pausing on objects that explain the man who lives there – a magazine photographer who has broken his leg on assignment. And it is a very hot day…

In a 1963 interview with Cinema magazine, Hitchcock described Rear Window as “very cinematic” despite the central character being static, “in one position, in one room, for the whole picture.” He talked about how close-up shots of James Stewart’s facial expressions were edited with shots of images he observes as a means of manipulating audience acceptance of his character. Naturally, Stewart’s character, Jeff, is very likeable and easily related to by viewers. It is through a continuing series of point-of-view shots, especially those depicting what Jeff sees with his binoculars, that the audience is swiftly maneuvered into sharing his perspective and his anxieties.

Rear Window is technically superb and enormously enjoyable. Along with Hitchcock’s visual pyrotechnics (Robert Burks, D.P.), the film features a sharp script by John Michael Hayes (his first of four for Hitchcock), with three old pros (Stewart, Thelma Ritter, Wendell Corey) and one newly minted pro (Grace Kelly) to handle clever character-defining dialogue. Raymond Burr doesn’t have much to say as the villain of the piece, but he’s goosebump-inducing scary in his climactic scene with Stewart.

What more can I say? Rear Window is a masterpiece I’ve seen countless times with more viewings to come.

 Rear Window, opening scenes


Walt Disney Productions: Lady and the Tramp (1955)

Trusty, Lady and Jock in Lady and the Tramp

The Disney zeitgeist enjoyed a colossal heyday during the 1950s. An entire generation of Americans, the Baby Boomers, was mesmerized by a series of Disney animated features, nature documentaries, live action feature films and its Mickey Mouse Club on TV.

Disney animation produced Cinderella (1950), Alice in Wonderland (1951), Peter Pan (1953), Lady and the Tramp (1955) and Sleeping Beauty (1959). From the documentary side came The Living Desert (1953) and The Vanishing Prairie (1954). Feature films included Treasure Island (1950), 20,000 Leagues Under the Sea (1954), Davy Crockett: King of the Wild Frontier (1955), its sequel Davy Crocket and the River Pirates (1956), Old Yeller (1957), The Shaggy Dog (1959) and Darby O’Gill and the Little People (1959).

The Tramp
So much great entertainment to choose from…Peter Pan, 20,000 Leagues, Old Yeller, The Shaggy Dog. But this choice was not so difficult, even with such an embarrassment of Disney riches. For me, it’s Lady and the Tramp, a colorful, heartwarming dog fairytale. Princess dog (Lady, a Cocker Spaniel) meets commoner dog (the Tramp, a homeless mutt) and their opposites-attract chemistry eventually leads to love. The dogs will contend with hardship and adversaries - a dog-hating aunt and her mischievous Siamese cats (“We are Siamese if you pleeease…”). Ultimately, though, they will end up heroically saving the day and be allowed to live happily ever after with Lady’s owners, “Jim Dear” and “Darling.” It’s adorable.

Legendary songstress Peggy Lee voiced the roles of Darling, the two cats (Si and Am) and Peg, a stray Pekingese who sings “He’s a Tramp,” an apparent allusion to her ex, Lady’s newfound beau. Other dog characters who help Lady and the Tramp include Jock, a neighborhood Scottie, and Trusty, a Bloodhound who was once a tracker but has lost his sense of smell. It’s adorable.


Dinner at Tony's

Marilyn Monroe: Some Like it Hot (1959)


Joe E. Brown and Jack Lemmon in Some Like it Hot

The 1950s were also Marilyn Monroe’s zenith years. She’d been only a starlet in the late ‘40s, with minor roles in minor films, and she lived not very far into the ‘60s. Throughout the ‘50s, however, she was a comet blazing across silver and Technicolor screens around the world.

She started the ‘50s with small roles in two classics, John Huston’s The Asphalt Jungle (1950) and Joseph L. Mankiewicz’s All About Eve (1950). Lesser films continued but, thanks to Howard Hawks and Gentlemen Prefer Blondes (1953), she was able to demonstrate her gift for comedy and shoot to the stratosphere in the glitzy/glamorous role of a dizzy but good-hearted showgirl, Lorelei Lee. Later that year she co-starred with Lauren Bacall and Betty Grable in another huge hit, How to Marry a Millionaire, playing a near-sighted Lorelei Lee type. By the time she made The Seven Year Itch (1955) for Billy Wilder, she no longer needed big name co-stars to help attract a wide audience, she was a superstar. At this point in her career Marilyn Monroe wanted to prove herself as a serious actress and she would next appear in Bus Stop (1956), a William Inge drama directed by Josh Logan. She finished the decade working with Billy Wilder again, this time on his comedy masterpiece Some Like it Hot (1959).

Marilyn Monroe as Sugar Kane
My Marilyn Monroe pick has to be Some Like it Hot, a flawless film. Penned by Wilder and his writing partner Izzy Diamond, a pair that produced some of the smartest, snappiest and most worldly screenplays ever, Some Like it Hot is classic screwball. Its multi-themed story line is pure farce, the dialogue, running at break-neck pace, boasts hilariously witty repartee, and there is more than one wacky romance at play.

In 1929 struggling musicians Joe (Tony Curtis) and Jerry (Jack Lemmon) have the misfortune to witness an infamous gangland massacre on St. Valentine’s Day. Desperate to get out of town incognito and fast, they deck themselves out in drag and head for Miami with Sweet Sue’s all-girl band. On the train south they meet the band’s luscious singer, Sugar Kane (Marilyn Monroe). Both men are smitten but Sugar only thinks of them as what they seem to be, gal pals. The plot goes wild once they reach Miami and Joe (now Josephine) connives to meet and seduce Sugar by way of a more masculine alter ego, and Jerry (now Daphne) struggles to deal with the love interest he’s managed to attract. And there’s the arrival of the mob to contend with. The roles of Joe/Josephine, Jerry/Daphne and Sugar Kane give the actors  – Curtis, Lemmon and Monroe – showcases to die for. And each of them delivers and then some. Directing Marilyn was a task that tested Wilder to the limit. But he was convinced that if he could be patient enough to coax it out of her, he’d get the performance he wanted. And he did.

Tony Curtis was on a roll when he came to Some Like it Hot. He’d had a solid hit with Trapeze (1956), co-starring with Burt Lancaster and Gina Lollobrigida. Perhaps his best film and juiciest role to-date had been in Sweet Smell of Success (1957), again with Lancaster. And he'd earned an Oscar nomination more recently with The Defiant Ones (1958), a race-themed drama opposite Sidney Poitier. Curtis would be in even greater demand after Some Like it Hot, having just given a top-flight comedic performance on a par with his two sizzling co-stars in one of 1959's biggest hits.

Glancing at Jack Lemmon’s filmography, one sees that Some Like it Hot firmly shifted him from supporting player into leading roles. He’d won a supporting Oscar a few years earlier for Mister Roberts (1955) but was nominated in the Best Actor category for the first time with Some Like it Hot. He would be nominated in that category again for Wilder’s The Apartment (1960) and be nominated six more times, winning for 1973’s Save the Tiger. He was on fire in Some Like it Hot as Jerry/Daphne and had the good fortune to share one of the best and most famous closing scenes in film history. It comes when, speeding in a motorboat with Osgood (Joe E. Brown), his suitor, Jerry/Daphne decides to come clean. Osgood has proposed marriage and isn’t accepting any of his/her lame reasons for refusing him. Finally, as he pulls the ladies wig he’s been wearing from his head, Jerry/Daphne’s voice drops to its normal register with the exclamation, “Oh, you don’t understand, Osgood, I’m a man!”  To which Osgood smiles a broad smile and replies quite calmly, “Well, nobody’s perfect.” You can't top that.

"How do they walk in these things?"
~

Click here to go to The Classic Movie and TV Café and links to the blogs participating in the National Classic Movie Day Blogathon.


32 comments:

  1. I admire the reasoning behind your dealing with the deliciously difficult task. Each title made me grin, and each critique gave me something to consider. Happy National Classic Movie Day!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Happy National Classic Movie Day to you, too, Paddy!

      Delete
  2. These are all marvelous choices! In our home, we always struggle with which is the best Hitchcock: REAR WINDOW or VERTIGO? I love them both. THE BAD AND THE BEAUTIFUL is one of the finest movies about Hollywood. The most unexpected among your choices LADY AND THE TRAMP. I love it, not only for the great Peggy Lee music, but for how it depicts the relationships among dogs, humans, and those sneaky Siamese cats.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. The Rear Window vs. Vertigo argument is an impossible one, Rick. I've had it with myself a number of times and finally just stopped and began enjoying each one for its singular perfection.
      I couldn't not include Lady and the Tramp having fallen deeply and entirely in love with it as a child. It's such an excellent example of the scope and quality of what Disney animation was producing in the '50s. I still think it was the studio's finest decade.

      Delete
  3. Love your list and love the fact that you included my all time favourite film! (Some Like it Hot)! About Roman Holiday's casting, I know Jean Simmons was considered for the role and I can picture her but I'm glad Audrey got it. I feel it was made for her and it really put her on the map!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. You have very fine taste, Virginie, for when it comes to comedy there has never been a better film than Some Like it Hot (some excellent comedies, yes, but not better). I didn't know Jean Simmons was up for the Princess Ann role and you're right, she could have done it very nicely but the part, as with Holly Golightly, fit Audrey Hepburn like a glove. A velvet glove.

      Delete
  4. I love your reasoning, and your writing, not just because I took two of the same films. Well done!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. As I mentioned in my comment on your blog, Jacqueline, great minds...

      Delete
  5. You surprised me by including “Lady and the Tramp” on your list! It is indeed adorable. I love when the kitties sing “We are Siamese if you don’t please” because you just know mischief lies ahead. I share your passion for “Rear Window” and was thrilled you included a picture of Raymond Burr. I really liked him and this role is the antithesis of the heroic lawyer Perry Mason.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Well, Toto, I felt strongly that the Disney studio should be included in any 1950s film review. Such great and prolific output through the decade - and so incredibly successful. And I have never loved any of its productions more than Lady and the Tramp.

      The question occurs whether Perry Mason might've somehow been able to get a "not guilty" verdict (or at least a reduced sentence) for Lars Thorwald had he taken him on as a client.

      Delete
  6. All wonderful choices, but I was especially cheered to see Lady and the Tramp. That film brought me so much happiness for so many years. Just reading about it made my heart skip a beat.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I've loved Lady and the Tramp a long, long time, and it was time to show it some love on the blog. What a perfect opportunity.

      Delete
  7. You know, Roman Holiday is one of those films that I've never gotten around to seeing. Your post has convinced me I must go for it. I had avoided To Catch a Thief until recently and was so glad I watched! The only other film on your list that I've seen is Some Like It Hot, and I love it, as I do most Billy Wilder films.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I hope you do see Roman Holiday soon. It's a film that I've always liked but that has grown on me more and more over the years. To Catch a Thief is irresistible, I think, a most witty and glamorous caper.

      Delete
  8. LOVE LADY AND THE TRAMP!! Its a love letter to dog lovers everywhere!! Nice choices btw!!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I seems my outlier choice is getting a lot of love. And why not, Lady and the Tramp is a Disney animation gem. I love it, too.

      Delete
  9. Great picks, Patty, and an outstanding post. I love The Bad and the Beautiful and Some Like It Hot -- and I've never seen Roman Holiday and Lady and the Tramp. I will have give Roman Holiday a try, especially.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks, Karen! As I mentioned in a reply above, I've always liked Roman Holiday, but it has moved more and more into my favorite zone over the years. I mean really, William Wyler, Dalton Trumbo, Audrey Hepburn, Gregory Peck...ya can't lose!

      Delete
  10. Some Like it Hot is one of my favorite all time films. Along with Woody Allen's Annie Hall, my favorite sound comedies. It was tough leaving it out of my top five, but as I mentioned in my post, I easily could have put down five Billy Wilder films, but limited myself one film, one director. The SLIH dialogue is the funniest ever. You're well aware of my love for Rear Window. Roman Holiday is a great romantic film. The Bad and the Beautiful is one of the great films about Hollywood and Lady and the Tramp. I really don't want to admit how long its been since I seen it as a kid. :)

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. This wasn't an easy process for me but, in the end, it was fun and worth it to figure out which films would make it into my final five. As you mention about Billy Wilder, I could easily have listed five Hitchcocks. And when I saw The Earrings of Madame de... on another participant's list, I was appalled that I'd forgotten Max Ophuls (who has two films that could've easily been on my list) and hadn't considered any of my favorite foreign films. Oh well, another day... :)

      Delete
  11. A clever way to approach a near-impossible task. These are all outstanding films, and I was happy to see Lady and the Tramp on the list – like you said, it's adorable. As for Roman Holiday, there are a few actresses who would have been superb in the role, but I don't think anyone could make the character sparkle like Audrey Hepburn.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. My approach to the subject may have been clever, but I came to it out of pure desperation. This approach did, however, make the selection process a whole lot easier.

      Delete
  12. Can't beat those choices! So far you're the only one who's listed THE BAD AND THE BEAUTIFUL, which is surprising. I enjoyed reading your description of it as larger than life and it is deserving as are all of the one you mention. I love how you arrived at the five too. Clever!

    Aurora
    Once Upon a Screen

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks, Aurora. I saw the Bad and the Beautiful on the big screen recently as part of a "Great Scores" series at a local theater. That may be why I "couldn't not" select it as my Minnelli film.

      Delete
  13. A fantastic list with some wonderful choices and a reminder that there are some beautiful films we need to watch again!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thank you! Yes, as I've visited the different participating blogs I've been reminded of many films that I need to revisit.

      Delete
  14. Great post Lady Eve and I'm glad I didn't participate this year and have to choose only five. I would never have been as rational as you. Your selections were all wonderful films and all very 50s in their different ways. Yet how can we capture the 1950s - Doris Day, Sophia Loren, John Wayne, Gene Kelly, Yul Brenner? Yes I'm glad I didn't have to choose. But kudos to you for your excellent reviews..

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks, Christian. I love so many films of the '50s that I would say, in the end, that while the films I selected are indeed favorites, I could easily have featured other films. As I've read other contributions to the blogathon, there are few films chosen that aren't also on my favorites list.

      Delete
  15. I like the approach you took here and your choices are well reasoned. The Bad and the Beautiful is something I need to see again. I think I was too young to fully appreciate the background and nods to other films at the time.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thank you! As for "insider" references in The Bad and the Beautiful, there are more than I mentioned. For one, the Leo G. Carroll character, a director, and his assistant are reportedly spoofs of Alfred Hitchcock and his wife Alma.

      Delete
  16. I loved your choices and your method to choose them. It's great to see Lady and the Tramp in one list, as well as the amazing The Bad and the Beautiful. And I also can envision Pier Angeli in Roman Holiday - she would have been perfect!
    Thanks for tthe kind comment!
    Kisses!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thank you, Le! As for Pier Angeli, it seems she could've had a bigger career and I'm not sure why she didn't.

      Delete